Home >  News >  March, 2012

Anesthesia Complication Lawsuit Settled for $851k

Patient argued that her sickle-cell disease plus inappropriate sedation caused adverse outcome.

Published: March 2, 2012

A South Carolina woman who underwent minor surgery and wound up suffering cognitive disabilities, allegedly as a result of anesthesia, has settled her lawsuit against a physician, CRNA and surgical facility for $851,000.

Sheriece Coltrain, 20, underwent surgery to remove abnormal cells from her cervix. While this type of procedure is often performed in office-based facilities, Ms. Coltrain's OB-GYN surgeon (unnamed in court records due to the terms of the settlement) opted to schedule it at an ASC (also unnamed).

The CRNA providing anesthesia for the case (also unnamed) intravenously administered deep sedation. Toward the procedure's end, Ms. Coltrain suffered cardiac and respiratory arrest, which resulted in anoxic brain injury. This impacted her ability to work or develop relationships, according to court records.

In her negligence lawsuit, Ms. Coltrain, who suffers from sickle-cell disease, faulted the physician for not recognizing the severity of her condition in planning the procedure. She and her attorneys argued that the CRNA administered an unnecessarily excessive level of anesthesia without ever offering a local anesthetic option, and breached the ASC's policies by performing monitored anesthesia care without an anesthesiologist's supervision. Attorney David Yarborough, who represented Ms. Coltrain, said it could not be determined which defendant initiated the decision to administer deep sedation.

The defendants pointed out that Ms. Coltrain hadn't disclosed to them that she'd taken pain medication on the morning of surgery. They maintained that they'd complied with the proper standards of care, and argued that her post-surgical cognitive deficits were pre-existing, citing her diagnosed ADHD and history of problems in school.

A mediated settlement was reached in October 2011. Attorneys for the defendants could not be located.

David Bernard

Also in the News...

One Small Incision in the Navel Is All That's Needed With New Lap Chole System
At ORX, a Tragedy Recounted Underscores The Urgency of Eliminating Medical Errors
ORX Attendees Learn How to Add Outpatient Total Joints
At ORX, an Expert Recipe for Improved Patient Safety
ORX Panel: Why You Should Post Your Prices Online
Study Finds Significant Savings With Outpatient Total Ankles
Tech Triumphs in Lawsuit Over Years of Unwanted Advances

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

Should We Use Video Laryngoscopes for All Intubations?

Why relegate the tool that gives you the best chance for success when difficult intubations arise to a backup role?

Pulmonary Hypertension a Major Concern in Pediatric Patients

The Future of Anesthesia

Our experts weigh in on the innovations, attitudes and practices they see down the road.