Home >  News >  June, 2011

Colonoscopy Tops Flexible Sigmoidoscopy for Colorectal Cancer Detection

Head-to-head comparison touts colonoscopy screening as the "gold standard."

Published: June 9, 2011

Colonoscopy is more effective than flexible sigmoidoscopy for the detection of colorectal cancer in elderly patients, according to researchers at the Mayo Clinic in Florida.

Medicare records of more than 25,500 patients 67 years or older in whom colorectal cancer was detected 6 to 36 months after lower endoscopy screenings revealed that left-sided cancer was 4 times more likely to be missed in patients who underwent sigmoidoscopy.

Yize Richard Wang, MD, PhD, a GI fellow at the Mayo Clinic and the study's lead author, admits he couldn't pinpoint exactly why sigmoidoscopies failed to identify cancer as reliably as colonoscopies did, but suggests the lower detection rates could be related to differences in bowel preparation and patient sedation as well as limited views of the colon obtained during sigmoidoscopies.

Although Dr. Wang says colonoscopy is a more expensive option, difficult for patients to prep for and results in post-procedure discomfort, he calls the popular screening method the "gold standard" for detecting or preventing colorectal cancer and advises older patients to opt for it over sigmoidoscopy.

That doesn't mean sigmoidoscopy is headed toward obsolescence. Thomas Semrad, MD, assistant professor of internal medicine at the University of California Davis Medical Center in Sacramento, says the test is easier to perform and less burdensome for patients, making it an appropriate choice in certain circumstances, notably for individuals who would avoid colorectal screening altogether over fears of prepping for and undergoing colonoscopy.

"Ultimately," points out Dr. Semrad, "the right test will be different for different patients and different health systems."

Daniel Cook

Also in the News...

Lawsuit: When PACU Lights Dimmed, Doc Asked Wife to Hold Penlight on Her Husband's Leaking JP Drain
R.I. Smoke Evacuation Legislation Becomes Law
Former Chief Nursing Officer Alleges Firing Retaliation for Reporting Safety Concerns
IV Drip Containing Formaldehyde Instead of Saline Kills Russian Woman, 28
Central Sterile Tech Shoots and Kills Nursing Supervisor at Alabama Hospital
Study Finds Psychosis Drug Amisulpride Reduces Nausea and Vomiting
Design Flaw Could Keep Bair Hugger Warming Blankets From Fully Inflating

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

Does Underwater Colonoscopy Amplify Polyp Detection?

Improve Your Polyp Detection Rates

Advances in flexible endoscopy enhance your ability to visualize the colon's walls and peer behind its folds.

What's New in Upper GI

The latest scope add-ons let gastroenterologists see and do more.