Home >  News >  June, 2014

Woman Awakens During Gall Bladder Surgery, Dies from Heart Failure

Jury agrees she should have been intubated, awards $7.9 million.

Published: June 23, 2014

The family of a woman who died in 2009 after complications during gall bladder surgery has won a $7.9 million malpractice judgment.

The lawyer for the family of 24-year-old Nicki Costner, who was 5-foot-2 and weighed 270 pounds, argued that she should have been intubated and given a general anesthetic during the laparoscopic procedure because she was obese.

According to news reports, Ms. Costner was given propofol, but woke up during the procedure, thrashed about, gasped for air and screamed in pain for 20 or 30 seconds before losing consciousness. Her condition deteriorated and she eventually went into cardiac arrest. She was airlifted to the University of Michigan hospital, but several days later she suffered another cardiac arrest and died.

"They should have used a general anesthetic and an endotracheal tube to decrease the likelihood of complications, they did not do that and she aspirated her stomach contents," said the family's attorney in a news release. "She stopped breathing, got very sick on the respirator, was transferred to (another hospital) and died five days later."

The jury returned a unanimous verdict in the case against anesthesiologist William E. Clay, MD, and William Beaumont Hospital in Grosse Point, Mich.

Spokesman Bob Ortlieb said the hospital plans to appeal, adding, "We believe the care that we provided was appropriate, but we are very sorry for the family's loss."

Dr. Clay did not immediately respond to a request for comment by Outpatient Surgery.

Jim Burger


Also in the News...

Bair Hugger Target of Suit Claiming It Caused Deadly Infection
UnitedHealthcare Accused of Withholding Payments to Indiana ASCs
ACS Improves Its Surgical Risk Calculator
When Small Hospitals Outperform Big Hospitals
California Out-of-Network ASCs Granted $9.5 Million Settlement in United Healthcare Underpayment Case
Cataract Surgeon Can't Be Blamed for Failure of Anesthesia Providers, Jury Finds
Joan Rivers's Docs Accept Blame, Agree to Pay "Substantial" Amount

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

Did Hospital Discriminate Against Allegedly Suicidal CRNA?

Court says hospital acted reasonably when it put her on extended leave.

Anesthesiologist Accused of Failing to Respond While Woman, 29, Slipped Away

Wrongful death suit also questions how well equipped freestanding surgical centers are to handle emergencies.

Pittsburgh Physician Accused of Poaching Lion in Zimbabwe

Alleged illegal hunt occurred months before recent "Cecil" outcry.