Home >  News >  August, 2014

Surgeon Fights "Butcher" Slur in Defamation Lawsuit

A chiropractor allegedly badmouthed the orthopod to a patient planning surgery.

Published: August 7, 2014

Dr. Howard Freedberg, MDChicagoland orthopedic surgeon Howard Freedberg, MD, has slapped chiropractor Pat Calcagno, DC, with a defamation lawsuit, accusing the back doc of calling him a "butcher" who's performing unnecessary surgeries to pay for a messy divorce. The suit seeks more than $50,000 in damages.

According to court documents, Dr. Calcagno talked to an injured high school football player in August 2013 about his upcoming knee surgery. When the 16-year-old shared that Dr. Freedberg would be performing the procedure, Dr. Calcagno allegedly questioned Dr. Freedberg's skills, claimed the surgeon scheduled the surgery because he needed money to cover the breakup of his marriage and told the boy to seek a second opinion before being operated on by "the butcher."

Court documents note Dr. Calcagno also suggested that undergoing care at DuPage County, Ill.-based Olympia Chiropractic and Physical Therapy, which he founded in 1997, would lead to a faster return to football action.

The teen was surprised by the comments, telling the chiropractor that Dr. Freedberg was a well-known surgeon. Dr. Calcagno reportedly responded that the orthopedic surgeon "takes pictures with famous people," but isn't well regarded in his field. The teen relayed the conversation to his parents, who alerted Dr. Freedberg.

"Dr. Freedberg is an incredibly accomplished surgeon and a leading member of the Illinois medical community," says his attorney, Lance Northcutt. "His skill as a surgeon and reputation as a doctor took a lifetime to build."

Mr. Northcutt says his client failed to obtain a retraction of the comments, adding, "This case was filed in response to an outright attack on his good name which was false and unjustified."

Dr. Calcagno did not return a call seeking comment. Dr. Freedberg — who refers to himself on his web page as "The Knee Expert" — reportedly performed the surgery on the teen as planned.

Daniel Cook


Also in the News...

Police: Director of Surgery Center Tried to Traffic 28g of Fentanyl
A Look at Health Care's Reimbursement Future at ORX
At ORX, Why Open Disclosure Bests Deny and Defend
Study Finds Patients Fare Better When the Surgeon is Female
At ORX, The Case for Giving Disruptive Docs a Second Chance
ORX Attendees Learn Why Patients Come Second
Study: "Frailty" a Better Predictor of Complications Than Age in Low-Risk Surgeries

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

News & Notes

"Drunk On Call"

Nurse at VA hospital assisted surgery while under the influence.

Did Short-Staffed Hospital Put Patients in Jeopardy?