Home >  News >  April, 2014

Doc Accused of Slapping Sedated Patients So Hard He'd Sometimes Leave Red Marks

Doc claims he was testing adequacy of anesthetic; hospital faces sanctions for allegedly ignoring complaints. UPDATE: No criminal charges to be filed against surgeon

Published: April 10, 2014

An orthopedic surgeon accused of slapping anesthetized patients in the buttocks and making crude comments about them is facing serious ramifications, and so is the hospital that reportedly ignored staff complaints about his behavior.

Michael C. Clarke, MD, is the subject of a CMS investigation, along with St. Joseph's Hospital Health Center in Syracuse, N.Y., according to a report.

Staff members say Dr. Clarke slapped patients so hard on the buttocks that he sometimes left red marks or hand prints. But according to federal investigators, the hospital ignored a staffer's complaint for more than a year. Other staffers say they didn't report the behavior because they thought nothing would be done or they were afraid to jeopardize their jobs.

The hospital's inaction could result in termination from Medicare and Medicaid, which cover most of its patients.

This raises the question: Are your staff members comfortable speaking up if they witness unsavory behavior by a physician? Would you respond immediately if they did?

Dr. Clarke, who moved to neighboring Crouse Hospital in February, is also the target of an investigation into possible criminal conduct, based on the same accusations. He reportedly has claimed that he slapped patients to test the adequacy of their spinal anesthetic, but 11 staff members interviewed by investigators said they'd never seen another physician do that. He's also accused of using sexually explicit language during procedures, sometimes directed at staff members.

Calls by Outpatient Surgery Magazine to Dr. Clarke and to James Lantier, his lawyer, were not returned.

* * * UPDATE on April 17 * * *

Dr. Clarke will not face criminal charges related to the investigation, according to the Onondaga County (N.Y.) District Attorney's office. "None of the witnesses described conduct that could be proven to be sexual in nature," the office said in a news release. "In order to charge a criminal offense it is necessary to have proof of the element of sexual gratification," and to have victims who've come forward, says District Attorney William J. Fitzpatrick. "In this case there is neither." St. Joseph's Hospital may still face sanctions.

Jim Burger


Also in the News...

Patient Claims Surgeon Wrongly Shared Her Before-and-After Plastic Surgery Pictures
Texas Docs Court CMS for OK to Expand
The Speakers Are Set for OR Excellence 2016
A Checklist Is Only as Effective as Team Using It
Stryker Acquires Pre-op Wipe Maker Sage Products
Hospital Fined $86K for Retained Object Can't Figure How It Got There
Furious at Administrators, Surgeon Allegedly Threatened to Get Assault Rifle

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

Texas Docs Court CMS for OK to Expand

Population needs dictate which physician-owned hospitals can build on.

Bill Seeks to Exempt Surgery Centers From Counting Toward 50% Threshold

Physicians who work in ASCs would avoid Medicare "meaningful use" payment penalties.

News & Notes