Home >  News >  May, 2013

Aetna Sues NJ ASC Over Out-of-Network Practices

Insurer claims it has overpaid $10M as a result

Published: May 22, 2013

Aetna has sued a New Jersey ASC for "damages and treble damages based upon fraudulent and excessive billing," according to a filing in U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey. The insurer claims it has overpaid Patient Care Associates, LLC, by $10 million as a result of PCA's "regularly submitt[ing] false and fraudulent health insurance claims … which misrepresent and inflate the actual charges for out-of-network services," says the suit.

According to court documents, physicians, some of whom hold financial interests in PCA, referred Aetna-covered patients to the ASC even though it's a non-participating center. "PCA and the physicians encourage patients to use PCA rather than a participating center and assure the patients that they will not be liable for any charges associated with the inappropriately charged out-of-network costs," says the suit.

Aetna claims that, from January 2010 to June 2012, it paid PCA approximately $10 million for these out-of-network procedures. The suit cites examples of what Aetna considers to be inflated charges: In May 2012, PCA submitted a bill for $83,778 for a knee arthroscopy (reimbursed at $6,973 by Medicare); in November 2011, PCA charged Aetna $193,831 for facet joint injections and ended up being paid $95,347 of that (Medicare reimbursement for the procedure is $405.90). The insurer is seeking to recover the overpayments, pre- and post-judgment interest, damages, lawyer's fees and costs of the suit.

A representative at PCA reached by phone said the facility had no comment. Request for comment from Aetna's legal representation was not returned.

Stephanie Wasek

Also in the News...

One Small Incision in the Navel Is All That's Needed With New Lap Chole System
At ORX, a Tragedy Recounted Underscores The Urgency of Eliminating Medical Errors
ORX Attendees Learn How to Add Outpatient Total Joints
At ORX, an Expert Recipe for Improved Patient Safety
ORX Panel: Why You Should Post Your Prices Online
Study Finds Significant Savings With Outpatient Total Ankles
Tech Triumphs in Lawsuit Over Years of Unwanted Advances

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

Hospital Terminates Medical Assistant, Citing Surgical Wound as Infection Risk

Court rules hospital's "ambiguous" infection control policy not enough to terminate employee.

California Out-of-Network ASCs Granted $9.5 Million Settlement in United Healthcare Underpayment Case

The 6-year-long lawsuit alleged that United Healthcare shorted the out-of-network ASCs millions.

FDA Drops Exparel's Marketing Restrictions