Home >  News >  May, 2013

Did Rushing Cause This Fatal Surgical Error?

Surgeon denies negligence in wrongful death case.

Published: May 21, 2013

Why did a laparoscopic cholecystectomy turn deadly: extensive scar tissue or the surgeon's shortcuts? We'll never know for certain because the wrongful death suit was settled during jury deliberations for $1,050,000, but the case hammers home the importance of good visualization during minimally invasive abdominal surgery.

On July 14, 2010, Alexander Park, MD, performed a laparoscopic cholecystectomy on Trellis Basham, 67, at St. Joseph's Hospital in Atlanta, Ga. Due to complications from extensive scar tissue, Dr. Park elected to abandon the laparoscopic procedure in favor of an open surgery, court records show. During the open procedure, Dr. Park encountered excessive bleeding and discovered a tear in the portal vein. Dr. Park called in a vascular surgeon to repair the vein, but by by this time Ms. Basham had already suffered a catastrophic blood loss. She died in the ICU shortly after the surgery.

Ms. Basham's adult children filed a suit against Dr. Park and his employer, Georgia Surgical Associates PC, for wrongful death. They argued that Dr. Park was behind schedule and, while rushing through Ms. Basham's surgery, inserted a trocar without proper visualization, which resulted in the portal vein injury.

Dr. Park denied any wrongdoing and contended that the laparoscopic surgery was complicated by excessive scar tissue that was blocking the gallbladder. However, Dr. Park admitted that he deviated from his standard procedure for non-emergent laparoscopic surgeries, court records show. Although it was standard practice for Dr. Park to first insert a Veress needle into the abdominal cavity to create space around the organs before inserting the trocar, he skipped this step in this instance and inserted the trocar without the typical visualization. Defense expert Joseph Mims, MD, testified that while Dr. Park's decision was not a deviation from the standard of care, it was extremely rare for a surgeon not to insert the Veress needle, court records show.

Dan O'Connor


Also in the News...

Senate Finance Committee Takes Aim at Concurrent and Overlapping Surgeries
Negligence Complaint Ties Lung Paralysis to Improper Placement of Regional Block
Surgeons Remove Thyroid Gland by Making 3 Small Incisions Inside the Mouth Underneath Lower Lip
Anesthesiologist Dealing with Fallout Following Racially Insensitive Facebook Post About First Lady
Bill Promotes Pricing Transparency and Protects Physicians From EHR Penalties
Donald Trump Picks Staunch Obamacare Critic Tom Price, MD, as U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services
Appendectomy Patients Don't Need an Overnight Stay

New to Outpatient Surgery Magazine?
Sign-up to continue reading this article.
Register Now
Have an account? Please log in:
Email Address:
  Remember my login on this computer

advertiser banner

Other Articles That May Interest You

The Constant Quest for Zero

Q&A with Peter J. Pronovost, MD, PhD, FCCM, the anesthesiologist and critical care physician who's dedicated to improving patient safety.

'Black Box' in Every OR

Surgery can take a lesson from aviation, says the surgeon who invented a device that records every step of surgery.

A New Way to Think About Retained Items

Studies on the psychology of counting helped shape AORN's updated prevention guideline.