Home > News  > November, 2012

Hospital Not Liable for Post-op Recovery Chair Mishap

Courts throw out patient's suit that nurses improperly reclined surgical chair and hurt his back.

Published:November 9, 2012

Categories:

Here's one you don't hear every day: A patient blamed a reclining post-op surgical chair for permanently injuring his back.

After his gastric bypass surgery about 5 years ago, Hershel Blood of Franklin, La., claims that 2 nurses who transferred him into the chair mistakenly let it recline too far back. Hence, his bad back. Sadly for Mr. Blood, the courts threw his case out for lack of evidence.

According to the malpractice suit, 2 nurses at Regional Medical Center of Acadiana in Lafayette, La., transferred Mr. Blood, 58, from his bed to a reclining surgical chair. After they'd completed the transfer, one nurse attempted to recline the chair, but mistakenly reclined it too far back. Mr. Blood alleged that "the sudden motion permanently injured his back." The suit alleges that RMCA failed to properly complete the transfer; failed to properly inspect or operate the surgical chair; and failed to meet the standard of care.

The Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit, affirmed the district court's decision to dismiss due to insufficient evidence.

  • Failure to transfer to the surgical chair. Mr. Blood alleged that RMCA failed to properly complete the transfer from his hospital bed to the surgical chair. However, his own testimony in district court revealed he was sitting in the chair — and, therefore, the transfer had been completed — when the incident happened. He presented no evidence indicating the transfer hadn't been completed.

  • Expert evidence not needed to prove standard of care. Although medical malpractice cases generally require expert testimony to prove the standard of care, Mr. Blood asserted he wasn't required to present such evidence because he believed (1) a medical review panel had instructed the court to find the use of expert opinion unnecessary and (2) the case falls under an exception that doesn't require expert testimony. The appeals court found neither an exception to be applicable, nor the panel's instructions to read as such.

  • Failure to visually and physically inspect the chair before transfer. The appellate brief asserted that, because the nurse failed to physically inspect the chair, the hospital breached the standard of care. However, an affidavit from a registered nurse stated that "it is necessary" to physically inspect the chair — but not by whom. The nurse who operated the chair said she believed the hospital's maintenance department inspected chairs, and Mr. Blood presented no contradicting evidence. Further, the medical review panel found no evidence indicating that RMCA improperly inspected or operated the surgical chair.

    "The chair broke or malfunctioned. It went straight back," says Mr. Blood when reached by telephone. "It felt like I reaggravated or pulled an old herniated disc. It still bothers me, but not like it did. I think it was simply their fault."

    Mr. Blood was assessed the costs of the appeal.

    Stephanie Wasek

    • © Copyright Herrin Publishing Partners LP. REPRODUCTION OF THIS COPYRIGHTED CONTENT IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. We encourage LINKING to this content; view our linking policy here

    Also in the News...

    Did Rushing Cause This Fatal Surgical Error?

    Does Your Insurer Have to Pay to Defend You?

    Stark Violations Might Cost Tuomey Healthcare System $357M

    Tech Walks Out on Surgical Case, Sues Hospital for Firing Him

    N.J. Considering Cosmetic Surgery Site Limits

    Colonoscopy Co-Pays are Covered, With a Catch

    How Are Compounder Recalls Affecting You?

    © Copyright Herrin Publishing Partners LP. REPRODUCTION OF THIS COPYRIGHTED CONTENT IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. We encourage LINKING to this content; view our linking policy here

     
    Have an account? Please sign in:
    Email Address:
    Password:

    DID YOU SEE THIS?
    Ophthalmology

    This Laser Works Better and Faster
    /_media/adv/web/images/2013/20130301_BFW_AR-300x250.gif

    Other Articles That May Interest You

    ASC Leader Looks Back on Boston Marathon

    Jay Hempe won't let bombings deter him from running another race.

    $1.2M Settlement in Anesthesia Supervision Case

    Whistleblower lawsuit cited University of California-Irvine for insufficient oversight of CRNAs and residents.

    Could Your Facility Use a Spark?

    7 quick pick-me-ups if your surgical center is sputtering along.