Subscriptions Advertising Resources About Us Contact Us
Create An Account Forgot Your Password?
Trouble logging in or creating an account? click here
Home This Month Archive Surveys E-Mall E-Weekly Building a Facility
Search OSM
Accrediting/Quality
Anesthesia
Bariatric Surgery
Building/Renovating
Business Management
Code/Bill/Reimburse
Outpatient Surgery E-Weekly

Joint Commission Cracks Down on Bullying

The abusive, manipulative and just plain nasty treatment that many healthcare professionals get from their peers on a daily basis has got to stop, s...

Study: Specialty Hospital Physician-owners More Likely to Refer Patients for Surgery

The physician-owners of specialty hospitals are more likely to refer patients to the facility for surgery, imaging and other procedures than non-own...

Efficacy of Cadaver Ligaments Questioned

Nearly one-fourth of cadaver ligaments implanted in young athletes during ACL reconstructions fail, a discovery that may promote the use of grafts t...

Home > Archive > August 2002
My Turn
Fostering Facility Civility
Patricia L. Raymond, MD, FACP
Some insist that you cannot control the obnoxious behavior of your doctors and your colleagues. They say that the only thing that you can control is your own reactions to such conduct.

This passive sentiment calls to mind the (slightly amended) biblical passage:

"The rain falls on the Just and the Unjust,
but the Just get wetter,
because the Unjust have just stolen the Just's umbrellas."


Being passive in the face of uncivil manners causes your outpatient facility atmosphere to be psychologically damaging. A mature, strong and appropriate response can alter that rude behavior. Haven't you gotten tired of being meek? Of being taken advantage of by the unjust?

I don't mean for you to be rude, mean or uncivil yourself. I don't want the Jedi Knight in you to go over to the Dark Side. You must learn how to stand your ground, and calmly insist on being treated in a polite fashion. You need to take the time necessary to teach your physicians and coworkers civil behavior.

Why should you bother?
Much of the responsibility for our ongoing nursing shortage, after low wages and erratic schedules, comes from incivility amongst the medical staff. Heated nurse-physician interactions depress nursing morale (Rosenstein, 2002) and contribute to staff shortages and departure from careers in medicine. Meanwhile, civil units have an easier time retaining their staff.

In addition to safeguarding our own welfare, we need to take control over rude behavior in our surgical centers for our patients' sakes as well. As studies in the ICU setting by Shortell (1994) and Knaus (1986) reveal, uncivil behavior amongst staff harms our patients. Patients in uncivil units experienced higher death rates or longer lengths of stay in the hospital.

I do not preach that insistence on respectful conduct will transform your associates' overall behaviors, enhance their personality forever or give them fresh, minty breath. However, "medical people"" are smart. And they are trainable. The pharmaceutical industry demonstrates this daily with their pens and pads of paper, subliminally schooling doctors to write their medications.

You will not be able to affect a life or a persona change, but you should be able to tutor your colleagues to act in a consistently appropriate manner when around you. You must simply begin to stand firm and be resolute that you will be treated civilly.

Meek for moxie
We need to teach outpatient surgery staff behavior modification techniques, both subliminal and overt, to cure our incivility epidemic. We deserve a sane, courteous, collaborative workplace.

Trade meek for moxie today. Take back your umbrella.

Dr. Raymond (PLRaymond@RxForSanity.com), a practicing gastroenterologist in Chesapeake, Va., invites you to visit her Web site (www.RxForSanity.com). Her book, "Bedside Manners: How to Cure the Incivility Epidemic in YOUR Hospital," is due out next year.

Already have an account? Please sign in:
Email Address:
Password:
Categories: Op-Ed/Letters/Email
Other Articles That May Interest You
My Turn
When It Comes to Handling ASC Issues, CMS Deserves a B
Letters & Corrections
Editor's Page
Sensing a Subtle Shift
69
Comment on this Article
You must be logged in to leave comments.
Recent Comments
You must be logged in to view comments.