How Regional Anesthesia Helped Us Cut Costs and Improve Patient Satisfaction In Our ASC
Nathan Schwartz, MD, and Emil Dilorio, MD,
The Ambulatory Surgery Center, Lehigh Valley, PA
To study the effects of regional anesthesia on patient care and costs, we completed a 16-month, non-randomized study of regional anesthesia techniques at our ASC. Our study included 1,626 outpatient orthopedic surgical cases, including 1,044 knee arthroscopies, 136 ACL repairs, 89 shoulder surgeries, 212 hand procedures, and 145 podiatric surgical procedures.
During the study, we analyzed the incidence of PONV, inpatient admissions, and patient satisfaction. We defined PONV as the presence of nausea or vomiting in the early postoperative period until discharge requiring anti-emetics or a prolonged stay beyond two hours.
We measured patient satisfaction by calling patients within 48 hours after discharge and asking for their overall level of satisfaction.
Prior to surgery, we sedated patients using a benzodiazepine agent, and if necessary, a low-dose, short-acting intravenous induction agent such as propofol or brevital. We then performed nerve regional anesthesia according to the following protocol:
- Knee arthroscopies: Intra-articular knee and portal block.
- ACL reconstruction: Femoral 3:1 block and intra-articular knee and portal block.
- Shoulder surgeries: Interscalene or brachial plexus block; suprascapular and superficial cervical plexus block.
- Hand surgery: Brachial plexus or intravenous regional anesthesia (Bier Block) or selective peripheral nerve block.
- Foot surgery: Ankle block.
We performed the femoral 3:1 block, interscalene, or brachial plexus block with the aid of a peripheral nerve stimulator (Stimuplex - Burron) using a standardized mixture of 20 cc of 2% lidocaine with 1:200,000 epinephrine and 20 cc 0.2% of ropivacaine. We performed Bier Blocks with 30-50 cc of 0.5% lidocaine. Peripheral nerve blocks were non-standardized; however, typically we used less than 10 cc of diluted lidocaine or ropivacaine.
We used minimal sedation on most knee arthroscopies and hand and foot cases. For patients undergoing ACL or shoulder surgeries, we administered nitrous oxide via LMA or endotracheal intubation, incorporating inhalational agents, muscle relaxants, and other agents as required for the safe completion of the procedure. Because of the effectiveness of the regional anesthesia we were generally able to use light levels of anesthesia and extubate the patients rapidly at the conclusion of the surgery.
Very few patients experienced significant postoperative pain; we were able to move most patients directly to our Level 2 PACU. If necessary, especially in the case of prolonged surgeries, we administered a "touch-up" of the block in the PACU with the initial or lower local anesthetic dosages. We evaluated street-readiness according to the Alderete score.
During the 16 months of the study, there were no hospital admissions for PONV or pain. Only eight patients, representing 0.3 percent of all the surgeries, required a PACU stay beyond two hours (these patients had received general endotracheal anesthesia). Sixty-seven patients, or about 3 percent, required rescue anti-emetic therapy during the PACU stay, and several patients noted late postoperative nausea, which we attributed to oral opioids prescribed by the surgeon. Significantly, all patients rated their satisfaction as "excellent" during the post-procedure telephone call.
We estimate that we saved $75 per procedure due to reduced use of post-op pharmacological agents such as analgesics and antiemetics, decreased nursing and ancillary personnel care, and decreased PACU stay.